Apple Homeview Impressions: Not Convinced!
Summary
AI summaries can be incomplete or wrong. Verify anything important against the original video.
Marques Brownlee provides a critical first look at the new Apple Homeview, a dedicated smart home display. He questions its value proposition and design choices compared to established competitors like Google and Amazon.
This review provides an in-depth analysis of the Apple Homeview, Apple's new central smart home controller that attempts to fill a gap in their ecosystem. The device serves as a smart home hub with a seven-inch square touchscreen, an A18 chip, and a new 'Homeview OS'. Brownlee explores its features, including account switching based on facial recognition, and how it interacts with other devices. However, he remains skeptical of its initial value, noting the high price point compared to competing products from Google and Amazon. He also critiques design decisions, such as the black bezels and the lack of native third-party apps, suggesting the device feels like a first-generation product that has yet to justify its cost for most users.
Verdict
A well-built display that feels like a first-generation product with limited utility and a difficult-to-justify price point.
Pros
Cons
Specs
Compared to
-
Google Nest Hub Max
Provides better personalized voice recognition at a lower price point.
-
Amazon Echo Hub
Offers more affordable smart home integration options.
Best for
Not for
Key Points
- 0:03 Overview of new Apple smart home products: HomePod mini 2, Apple TV 4K, and Homeview.
- 0:55 Core functionality of Homeview as a smart home dashboard and controller.
- 1:53 Physical design details: 7-inch square screen, color-matching base, articulating arm, and black bezels.
- 2:26 Pricing comparison with Google Nest Hub Max and Amazon Echo Hub.
- 5:12 Software features: Homeview OS, Apple Watch-inspired clock faces, and lack of App Store support.
- 6:54 Account switching functionality using camera-based facial recognition, not full FaceID.
- 9:12 Overall verdict: Lack of compelling value proposition for most users at this stage.
- 9:57 Voice recognition limitations compared to existing HomePod devices.
Worth watching if: You are a smart home enthusiast curious about Apple's entry into the display market or if you're deciding whether this device is a necessary addition to your existing home automation setup.
Get every Marques Brownlee video extracted like this
One daily email with structured extracts of every channel you follow. Free tier covers 15 videos a month.
Sign in with GoogleNo credit card. Free tier forever.